Even if bell peppers aren’t grown locally, you can still get a high quality pepper at the store since they ship well.
When are peppers in season?
US grown peppers are actually available year-round, thanks to our different growing climates. California ships peppers from April until December, with peak season from May through July. Florida ships peppers from October through July, with peak in March and April.
Farmers market or grocery store?
Peppers actually ship and store really well, so grocery store options will be fairly similar to the ones at a farmers market.
However, the farmers market will offer more varieties. They might have purple or even pale yellow (almost white) bell peppers. Farmers often sell other sweet pepper varieties too, like Italian frying peppers (Cubanelle) or fresh pimento peppers.
How to buy & store
To pick the best peppers, make sure the pepper is firm (soft spots indicate a decline in quality). Also look for shiny, tight skin – wrinkles are a sign that it is losing moisture and isn’t as fresh. Unlike tomatoes and other more delicate produce, peppers actually ship quite well, so if they come from another part of the country, their quality should still be pretty good.
- Whole peppers: put them in the crisper drawer in an open plastic bag. Green peppers can last 1-3 weeks. Yellow, orange, and red tend to have a shorter life span since they are more ripe, lasting 5- days to 2 weeks.
- Cut peppers: store in an airtight container in the fridge for about 3 days.
- Cut peppers can also be frozen, with or without blanching.
Should I buy organic?
If it fits in your budget, yes. The non-organic health risk of the pesticides found in sweet peppers is high from the US (very high when from Mexico). Based on the information that Consumer Reports published, that means you would need 1-5 servings in a day to exceed the level of safety set by the EPA (or just 1 serving if it’s from Mexico).
The data collected by the EPA looks at the toxicity and amount of each pesticide found in the edible portions of the fruit. The full details can be found over on the Consumer Reports website.
Why are red bell peppers more expensive?
Green peppers haven’t spent as much time ripening on the plant, which usually means you get a bigger harvest as weather and pests haven’t had as much time to cause problems. Because of this, they are almost always less expensive and first to arrive in farmers markets.
Another factor that makes green bell peppers cheaper, is that continuous harvesting makes the plant produce more. When left to ripen to yellow, orange, or red, the plant produces less peppers overall.
So the increased price for yellow, orange, and red peppers, while pretty high, seems fair. It’s also worth knowing that the price of all colors will be lower while they are in-season.
Sweet peppers aren’t necessarily sweet – rather they aren’t hot. Bell peppers are the most common sweet pepper and come in a variety of colors with different flavor attributes. Find out how color affects the flavor, along with other sweet pepper varieties in the sweet pepper produce guide.
Working with the bitterness in green bell peppers:
You might not like the bitterness in bell peppers and prefer yellow, orange or red ones. While using green peppers in salads or other fresh dishes might not be in your wheelhouse, there are still some uses to consider.
The bitterness can work in your favor if you add them to rich or sweet dishes, since that bitter flavor balances it out. Green bell peppers on a pizza with all of that rich cheese and sausage? Perfect. On a salad with bitter greens – not so good.
Check out “Dealing with bitter bell peppers.”
Up next: bell pepper recipes
Over 50 recipes from 14 types of dishes, including stuffed bell peppers, pasta, soups, and stews. The “classic bell pepper” section includes recipes that try to make use of the bitterness of bell peppers. Whereas other recipes rely solely on the sweeter red, orange, and yellow varieties.